AUSTRALIAN GOOD FOOD GUIDE - Home of the Chef Hat Awards

The Best Italian Restaurants That Go Beyond the Basics


Whether it's a delicate swirl of handmade pasta, a wood-fired pizza kissed with spice, or an indulgent plate of veal marsala paired with a spritz, Italian dining has evolved well past red-checked tablecloths and cliché carbonara. Across Melbourne, Sydney, Brisbane and Cairns, a new generation of venues is redefining what Italian food means—honouring tradition while embracing innovation. Here are five standout destinations where the food is bold, the wine lists are curated and the passion is palpable in every bite.

SUD Food & Wine – Melbourne CBD, VIC

With an enduring legacy in the heart of the city, SUD Food & Wine has become synonymous with Southern Italian hospitality and elegance. Now in a refreshed Lonsdale Street location, it continues to charm guests with a refined yet warm ambiance that caters to business lunches and intimate evenings alike. The space itself echoes rustic Italian flair with a contemporary twist, while the evolving menu reflects the chef’s devotion to regional produce and time-honoured technique.

The Best Italian Restaurants That Go Beyond the Basics

Expect ever-changing daily dishes that showcase the best of the season, often accompanied by a curated selection of wines sourced from across Italy’s diverse terroirs. Favourites include duck and pork meatballs in a rich Pomodoro sugo, alongside pasta highlights like maccheroni with fiery nduja and slow-cooked pork shoulder. For something heartier, the lamb shoulder slow-roasted to tender perfection, served with pesto and a red wine jus, is a standout.

Make your next CBD dinner one to remember—book a table at SUD and experience the heart of Southern Italy.

Itahlia Restaurant – Sunbury, VIC

Hidden within the Sunbury Cinema Complex, Itahlia Restaurant offers an unexpected escape into old-world Italian charm with a modern Australian sensibility. It’s the kind of place where locals linger over long meals and newcomers instantly feel at home. With its warm, rustic interiors and welcoming service, Itahlia is as much a community favourite as it is a culinary destination—perfect for casual lunches, cosy date nights or family celebrations.

The Best Italian Restaurants That Go Beyond the Basics

But the real draw is the food—especially the famed wood-fired pizzas, which have developed a near-cult following. One must-try creation pairs Moroccan-spiced lamb with red onion, tomato, and a melt of feta and mozzarella, finished with a cooling swirl of tzatziki and a pop of coriander. On the pasta front, creamy fettuccine loaded with chicken, avocado and garlic delivers the kind of comfort food nostalgia that never goes out of style.

Craving a slice of something special? Reserve your table at Itahlia and let the feast begin.

Pizza Da Noi – Glebe, NSW

Step inside Pizza Da Noi on St Johns Road in Glebe and you’ll feel like you've just walked into Nonna’s kitchen—if Nonna had a penchant for crafting consistently excellent pizza and pasta for the masses. A family-run gem since 2014, this restaurant has built its name on a dough recipe passed down through generations, offering a nostalgic yet elevated dining experience in a warm and relaxed setting.

The Best Italian Restaurants That Go Beyond the Basics

Start with chargrilled octopus tossed through rocket, tomato and olives before diving into handmade gnocchi drenched in gorgonzola, pesto or classic Napoletana. Pizza lovers can rejoice in options that go beyond the usual suspects—try a version loaded with eggplant, prosciutto, caramelised onion, bocconcini and parmigiano. For something more indulgent, the veal marsala with creamy mushroom sauce is a rich and velvety main that pairs beautifully with an Aperol Spritz.

Say sì to your next Italian night—book your spot at Pizza Da Noi and let tradition lead the way.

Ollie’s Italian – Cairns, QLD

Situated on the picturesque waterfront of Marlin Parade, Ollie’s Italian is as close as you’ll get to Positano without leaving the country. With sweeping views of Trinity Inlet and the reef beyond, this chic venue pairs sophisticated interiors with equally refined flavours. Whether you're sipping on a glass of vino as the sun dips behind the water or indulging in a luxurious meal, the mood here is one of coastal Italian escapism.

The Best Italian Restaurants That Go Beyond the Basics

Seafood and steak lovers are in for a treat—every element of the menu is crafted in-house, from artisan pasta to perfectly aged cuts of meat. Begin with calamari fritti elevated by paprika salt and a hit of zesty lemon, before moving on to a standout main like grilled duck breast served atop garlic parsnip purée, with crisp parsnip shards and a Cointreau-spiked red wine jus. The flavours are bold, layered and designed to impress.

For waterfront dining with serious Italian soul, make a booking at Ollie’s tonight.

RUSTICHELLA Pasta Bar – Nundah, QLD

RUSTICHELLA Pasta Bar is a love letter to Emilia-Romagna, brought to life in Brisbane’s Nundah neighbourhood by two proud Emilian natives. With a menu steeped in Northern Italian tradition and a focus on handmade pasta and underappreciated wine varietals, this family-run venue celebrates craftsmanship and simplicity in equal measure. The setting is cosy and contemporary, creating a space where serious foodies and casual diners alike feel right at home.

The Best Italian Restaurants That Go Beyond the Basics

Start with rustic appetisers like crostini topped with rich Bolognese and shaved Parmesan or opt for the vibrant tomato bruschetta. The pasta here is where the magic lies—tagliatelle served with a slow-cooked pork and beef ragu, enriched with a touch of cream, is a masterclass in balance and technique. For something equally satisfying, try the ricotta and parsley tortelloni finished with butter and sage. Sweet endings like hazelnut chocolate pudding seal the deal.

Treat yourself to a true taste of Emilia—secure your seat at RUSTICHELLA Pasta Bar now.

Italian cuisine may be rooted in tradition, but as these five restaurants prove, it’s anything but static. From housemade pasta to daring pizza toppings and waterfront fine dining, these venues take la dolce vita to exciting new heights—while staying grounded in the flavours that made Italian food beloved in the first place.

Featured Locations

Italian    $$$$$

SUD Food & Wine

Bringing Southern Italy directly to your plate, SUD Food & Wine on Lonsdale Street in the heart of Melbourne’s CBD has been a cornerstone of the city’s culinary scene for more than two decades. Rec...

Italian    $$$$$

RUSTICHELLA Pasta Bar

Honouring the culinary heritage of two Emilian natives and bringing the authentic flavours of their homeland to Nundah, discerning Brisbane foodies head to RUSTICHELLA Pasta Bar on Aspinal Street t...

Italian    $$$$$

Ollie's Italian

Discover Modern Italian dining at Ollie's on the exclusive waterfront dining precinct of Marlin Parade in Cairns. With stunning views of Trinity Inlet and the Great Barrier Reef, you will feel like...

Italian    $$$$$

Itahlia Restaurant

Tradition meets taste and every meal feels like coming home at Itahlia Restaurant on Horne Street in Sunbury. Nestled in Sunbury Cinema Complex, this restaurant has become a cherished local favouri...

Italian    $$$$$

Pizza Da Noi

A family-run restaurant established in 2014, Pizza Da Noi on St Johns Road in Glebe opened its doors with a pizza recipe that has been enjoyed by generations of families for more than 40 years. Wit...

Want more AGFG?
Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest articles & news...