AUSTRALIAN GOOD FOOD GUIDE - Home of the Chef Hat Awards

5 Aussie Dishes That Shouldn’t Have Worked – But Absolutely Did


Australia’s dining scene has always celebrated the bold and the boundary-pushing. Our Chefs thrive on risk - blending cultures, ingredients and instincts in ways that sometimes make diners raise an eyebrow…right before they fall in love.

These five dishes from fearless Aussie Chefs prove that when creativity leads, the impossible can taste sublime.

David Thompson’s Durian and Coconut Sticky Rice

In Bangkok, David Thompson found beauty in contradiction - and brought it home to Australian palates unafraid of adventure. His durian and coconut sticky rice dares diners to fall for what’s often called the world’s smelliest fruit.
 
5 Aussie Dishes That Shouldn’t Have Worked – But Absolutely Did
Photo credit: Tiny Urban Kitchen.

At first, the aroma hits like a wall, pungent and primal but as the sweet coconut cream wraps itself around the rice and fruit, something transcendent happens: the funk transforms into fragrance, the strangeness into seduction. It’s not just dessert - it’s devotion to authenticity.

Josh Niland’s Tuna ‘Prosciutto’

Fish treated like meat? Josh Niland didn’t just ask the question - he proved the answer. By hanging and curing tuna belly as if it were pork, Josh upended centuries of seafood convention.

5 Aussie Dishes That Shouldn’t Have Worked – But Absolutely Did

His tuna ‘prosciutto’ is a marvel: glossy, deep crimson slices that melt on the tongue, offering the salty umami of aged meat with the ocean’s whisper beneath. It’s a dish that challenges our perception of sustainability and waste, redefining what seafood can be when treated with reverence and imagination.

Danielle Alvarez’s Burnt Carrot with Labneh and Dukkah

At first glance, it looks like a mistake - a carrot charred to the edge of ruin. Danielle Alvarez, ever the champion of humble ingredients and soulful cooking, knew exactly what she was doing. The burn gives way to sweetness, caramel dripping into smokiness, while creamy labneh cools and dukkah crunches alongside.
 
5 Aussie Dishes That Shouldn’t Have Worked – But Absolutely Did
 
The dish feels almost elemental - fire, earth and patience captured on a plate. In Alvarez’s hands, a blackened carrot becomes a love letter to simplicity and restraint.

Andrew McConnell’s Lamb Tartare with Pickled Mussels

Raw lamb and seafood - together? Even Andrew’s staff raised an eyebrow when he first plated it at Cumulus Inc. but somehow, it sings. The delicate lamb, hand-cut and seasoned, meets the briny bite of pickled mussels in a collision of land and sea that feels strangely inevitable.
 
5 Aussie Dishes That Shouldn’t Have Worked – But Absolutely Did

The acid sharpens the meat’s richness, the saltwater tang brings it alive. It’s the kind of dish that leaves you shaking your head, smiling, wondering how it could ever make such perfect sense.

Lennox Hastie’s Flame-grilled Pineapple with Black Pepper Caramel

Lennox Hastie has built his career on coaxing magic from fire, but even his loyal diners didn’t expect dessert to smoulder like this. Pineapple, blistered over open flame until its sugars darken and its flesh softens, meets a glossy caramel infused with black pepper.

The heat of spice, the smoke of char, the bright tropical sweetness - they clash, they dance, they fall into balance. Every bite is a flicker of contradiction that lingers like embers on the tongue.
 
5 Aussie Dishes That Shouldn’t Have Worked – But Absolutely Did
 
These dishes are proof that genius often walks a fine line between folly and brilliance. From the kitchens of Australia’s daring Chefs come reminders that food isn’t about following rules - it’s about rewriting them.

In every burnt edge, every unexpected pairing, every improbable success, they remind us that sometimes, the best things in life are the ones that shouldn’t have worked at all.
Want more AGFG?
Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest articles & news...